Friday, September 27, 2013

belonging

I learned last week that my ex has been dumped, and I've been feeling a surprising amount of pity... with just a tinge of "see? *sigh* I told you so".  There should be a word for this feeling.  Probably in German.  The flip side of schadenfreude.

I'm not talking about my ex-lover.  I'm talking about my ex-church.

I learned this week my ex-church has been dumped by both of its settled pastors.  Both.  At the same time.  After just three years.

Ouch.

Morbidly curious, I went to the web site and listened to a joint sermon from the pastors after they informed the congregation that they would be leaving.  After all the "God calling" bullshit, they gave two refreshingly frank reasons.  First, they detail how stress of the job was causing serious health problems in them and/or their family.  I have a lot of respect for the public vulnerability that such an admission requires.  Churches have a tendency to eat their pastors for lunch.  With all the talk in the news about why scientists leave science, a lot of institutions can learn from their example

For their second refreshingly frank reason, I am going to quote them directly:
"Another factor is that both of us have experienced loneliness in doing this work in this place.  It is sort of ironic and strange to consider that in doing work with a congregation of 600 people, we could feel lonely."
And this is where I sighed.  I told you so.  This is why I left the church.  Those years that I tried to make it work, despite hundreds of hours of committee meetings and minutes and spreadsheets and heartache and brainstorming and really the absolute best I had to give, I never once was invited to a church member's house for dinner.  Not once.  When I left, even my leaving letter was not acknowledged.  I still get mailings from them asking for money.

But still.  What is a church to do?  Despite my good riddance stance, I felt the sting of the remarks shortly after in the joint sermon:
"...Pastors need friends and a support network completely outside of the church.  I'll just be honest with you. This has been very hard to do in Bellingham.  It was hard for your last set of pastors.  Over the past three and a half years, neither of us has been able to find a support network within the city of Bellingham, and it hasn't been for lack of trying.  This is something we're going to urge leadership to consider and reflect on in calling the next pastors."
Well.  What the hell is one to do?  I grew up in the nod-and-smile California, spent some time in the what-the-fuck-did-I-do-to-you Northeast, and have found home in the cult-of-personal-space Northwest.  I do resonate with their grief.  It is truly hard to make friends in this corner of the country.  But what is church leadership to do?  Pick up the church and move it?  No.  What they need to do is know themselves.  Hire (fuck that calling bullshit) a pastor who knows himself/herself well.

And yet.  Their point is well taken.  Nothing works without that sense of being where one is meant to be.  We call that belonging, we call that community... isn't that what we all want?  Butts in the pews or women in science or whatever.  We all want to feel like we belong.  Institutions need to figure that out what belonging looks like and how to make it happen to keep the ones that matter.

My poor ex.  We don't talk anymore, but they're close to my heart.  Wish there was a German word for that.