"Maybe she didn't want the raise."
-- undergraduate student, overheard at a conference for undergraduate women in physics in response to data that women make less money than men in the same position
This statement has stuck with me. Maybe because I took those Women's Studies classes all those years ago, so I know the stats are real. And I felt some affinity with the middle-aged speaker delivering them. I felt her surprise at the push-back she got from the young women in the audience. I shared her a shock at the young woman who said that maybe the woman (singular) in question didn't want to make more money than her boyfriend and so declined the raise.
There are, I think, two assumptions going on here. Here is my response to that undergraduate.
Your first assumption is this: "I make my own reality." The fundamental belief that you have control over your lives, professional and private, that the political is not actually personal. That averages don't apply to you because you can make choices, the right choices. That nothing happens to you without your permission.
The reality, however, is that a career in science (and life, really) has twists and turns that you will not be able to control. Some of the key decisions in your professional life will be made not based on your talent, but on the perception of "fit", or long-nursed grudges, or the vagaries of committee membership, or old-fashioned luck. Furthermore, you may find yourself as a member of a team -- professionally and perhaps personally -- that requires you to compromise in ways that are not in the best interest of the advancement of your career. In that case, there will be no right choice.
The reality, however, is that a career in science (and life, really) has twists and turns that you will not be able to control. Some of the key decisions in your professional life will be made not based on your talent, but on the perception of "fit", or long-nursed grudges, or the vagaries of committee membership, or old-fashioned luck. Furthermore, you may find yourself as a member of a team -- professionally and perhaps personally -- that requires you to compromise in ways that are not in the best interest of the advancement of your career. In that case, there will be no right choice.
Your second assumption is this: "I'm better than those underpaid women." That's the dangerous subtext to your comment. Those women who suffered under discrimination, they just weren't as smart as you are. That was then, this is now. You'll rise above because you are more talented, more driven, more... pretty? Because you will rise above the past. Because you, due to the tremendous force of your personality, will be judged on the scientific merit of your wok.
Here's what you don't yet know, the truth that we hide from the undergraduates. If you are the smart, hard-driving scientist you think you are, you will be judged as unfeminine. What you think of as smart will be labeled as abrasive, what you think as assertive will be judged as aggressive, and because of it you will be marginalized, overruled, and overlooked for advancement. But if you meet the expectations of feminine, you will not ask for the raise. You will not threaten to take a position at another school. You will do outreach and service, which everyone knows is not valued. With full feminine humility, you will not go up for full when your male colleagues do. You will have children and care for them more than your work... or be expected to anyway. In short, you will not get that raise. You will be damned if you do, and damned if you don't, and learn that there actually is no soft middle ground to "fit" in between a rock and a hard place.
So, my dear, be gentle as you toss judgments to those who have paved your way. When your time comes, when you hear them say that maybe you just didn't want the degree or just didn't want the position or just didn't want the promotion, you will need allies. You will need me.