I wish we talked more in this society about doing something because it is the right thing to do. I wish we talked less of personal cost and gain and more about personal integrity. Provide health care for people not because it is cheaper than emergency medicine, but because it is the right thing to do. I heard Michelle Obama say in a speech recently that to whom much has been given, much is expected. And I've carried the thought around with me, holding it up around my life to see where it fits.
Rather than tell my students that they should treat each other with respect because they might have something to gain from each other, I want to say that they must treat each other well because it is the right thing to do. Because not a single one of them has not been blessed, and therefore from each one of them, much is expected. That each time they crap on another person, they give away a little bit of the only thing that is truly theirs and the only thing that really matters and the only thing that they should jealously be guarding, their integrity.
At its best, church and religion can teach us about why we do the right thing by each other. At its best, we can learn from time we are tiny children the habits of love and justice. We can learn that we are bound to each other in community, held together by who we are as individuals of integrity. At its worst, of course, church is a club with a funny dues structure that instills fear and groupthinking to ensure the survival of the institution. And as for comfort, insight, and inspiration? Those are probably just gravy. Nice when they come, but they can come just as easily from a weathered tree or a pristine snowfield or sunshine on bare skin.
Having said all that, the reason why we don't talk more about doing the right thing is probably that we don't know what it is. Believing in the importance of and even deeply wanting integrity is hampered by the difficulty of discerning what the right thing to do actually is. Maybe slicing and dicing myself and giving the pieces away is just trying to get brownie points on some universal score card, patting myself on the back for being so selfless... the opposite of integrity. But it seemed like the right thing to do. There are times these days when I rather think that the right thing to do is to walk softly in the world, to do no harm. If I can lead a life that has some peace and beauty in it, if I can treat myself with care and respect, then that might be plenty. That might be what is expected of me, what I should expect of myself.
But I still think that in a universe run by thermodynamics toward disorder, creating the patterns of personal relationships is a higher call. So I keep dipping my toe into community and cannot shake the feeling that it is the right thing to do.